Harley-Davidson vs. Indian Motorcycles: A Battle of American Legends

Harley-Davidson vs. Indian Motorcycles: A Battle of American Legends

When it comes to iconic American motorcycle manufacturers, two names stand out above the rest: Harley-Davidson and Indian Motorcycles. These legendary brands have captured the hearts and souls of motorcycle enthusiasts for over a century, creating a rivalry as storied as their histories. In this article, we'll take a closer look at the enduring competition between Harley-Davidson and Indian Motorcycles.


Founded in 1903 in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, by William S. Harley and the Davidson brothers, Harley-Davidson has become synonymous with the American motorcycle experience. Their signature V-twin engines and distinctively styled bikes have made Harley-Davidson a cultural icon. From the rugged Sportster to the classic Road King and the rebellious Fat Boy, Harley-Davidson offers a wide range of models, each designed to cater to various riders and preferences.

Harley-Davidson's reputation is not just built on its bikes but also on its thriving community and lifestyle. The brand has a passionate following, with Harley Owners Group (H.O.G.) members participating in rallies, events, and group rides worldwide. The distinctive sound of a Harley engine and the feeling of freedom it represents are deeply ingrained in American pop culture.

Indian Motorcycles: The Resurrection

Indian Motorcycles, founded in 1901 in Springfield, Massachusetts, has a history as rich as Harley-Davidson's. Indian was a dominant force in early American motorcycling, known for its powerful engines and innovation. The rivalry between Indian and Harley-Davidson was fierce during the early 20th century, with each company vying for supremacy in the growing motorcycle market.

After facing financial troubles and changing ownership over the years, Indian Motorcycles underwent a revival in 2011 when it was acquired by Polaris Industries. The brand was reborn, introducing a new lineup of bikes that paid homage to its storied past while incorporating modern technology and design. Models like the Indian Scout, Chief, and Chieftain have garnered attention for their quality and performance.

Key Differences

  • Heritage: Both brands have deep-rooted histories, but Harley-Davidson has maintained a continuous presence in the motorcycle market since its inception. Indian, on the other hand, experienced a hiatus before its resurgence in the 21st century.


  • Styling: Harley-Davidson motorcycles are often associated with a rugged, classic design, while Indian has embraced a more retro-modern aesthetic, blending vintage and contemporary elements.


  • Performance: Both manufacturers produce powerful bikes, but Indian has gained a reputation for its exceptional handling and advanced technology in recent years, appealing to riders seeking a blend of tradition and innovation.


  • Community: Harley-Davidson boasts one of the most extensive and passionate rider communities in the world, while Indian is actively building its own dedicated following.

Search By Year, Make, and Model

Shop with confidence.

We are the first to offer an easy online lookup for motorcycle lighting. Find the right size lights with the right connectors the first time without guessing. Our online database is updated regularly to ensure the most up to date and complete coverage in the industry.

Fast and Free shipping

Enjoy fast and free shipping to anywhere in the continental US on all orders.